ALEX Institute / AI / AI Sovereignty · Module 4
Track D · AI Sovereignty, module 4. Wikiversity · about 1.3 h reading (15,362 words).
This syllabus and assorted materials have been created and curated from the 2021 Research Sprint run by the Digital Asia Hub and Berkman Klein Center for Internet Society at Harvard University. In collaboration with the Global Network of Internet & Society Centers (NoC), the Digital Asia Hub and the The Berkman Klein Center for Internet & Society brought together collaborators from the two co-hosting organizations and their global partners to explore the evolving normative concept of digital self-determination as an enabler of—or at least contributor—to the exercise of autonomy and agency in the face of shrinking choices in a world that is increasingly constructed, mediated and at times even dominated by digital technologies and digital media, including the underlying infrastructures, questions of control, power and equity become more critical. Visitors are invited and encouraged to explore the materials and use them where appropriate in learning experiences.
This syllabus explores the evolving normative concept of “digital self-determination” as an enabler of - or at least contributor - to the exercise of autonomy and agency in the face of shrinking choices. In a world that is increasingly constructed, mediated and at times even dominated by digital technologies and digital media, including the underlying infrastructures, questions of control, power and equity become more critical.
In contemporary ethics debates, the notion of digital self-determination is invoked as a term to describe the possibility and realization of human flourishing as it relates to the use of digital technologies and their affordances. In policy debates, the concept has gained prominence in broader discussions about digital autonomy and digital sovereignty. Several efforts by governments and civil society organizations are underway to examine how civic and economic participation in the digital space can be enhanced based on the value of digital self-determination.
The notion of digital self-determination requires exploration from different perspectives and across cultural contexts. It invites examination of the concept both in theory and practice. This syllabus provides resources and learning materials that consider what digital self-determination means and requires at the individual level, for instance regarding people’s ability to decide for themselves what data they want to disclose, to whom, under what conditions, and with what benefits. It also engages with questions at the structural and systemic level, such as barriers to exercising such choices, and the stakes and consequences of certain design decisions.
While questions of control over personal data will be a cross-cutting theme throughout the syllabus, other important dimensions of self-determination in the digitally networked will be examined as well, for instance with regard to self-expression and participation in civic life and the digital economy, or relationship-building and well-being.
This syllabus also discusses the social contexts and conditions surrounding the notion of digital self-determination and see it in interaction with values such as digital solidarity and realizations of collective embeddedness that are in contrast to individualistic accounts of human flourishing. While the challenges and roadblocks to digital self-determination have taken center stage in public discourse, additional attention will be given to the manifestations of and future opportunities for self-determination across digital spaces and contexts, including efforts aimed at creating “trustworthy” data spaces, data cooperatives, and related models.
Blending theoretical and practical perspectives, this syllabus's materials and artifacts embrace global voices and experts from many disciplines and professionals.
On each of the module pages, you will find an introduction, some external resources to explore, and content created during the sprint to help learners better explore the topic. Learners can explore it in sequence or just the modules that are most relevant (i.e. they are not entirely interdependent).
| Module | Topic | Brief description |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Beginning Inquiries | In this module, we take our first steps in exploring that question through three very different lenses highlighted by the speakers. By the end of this module, learners should have expanded some of their thinking and consideration about the concept. |
| 2 | Digital Self-Determination- An Approximation | This module introduces the concept of digital-self determination and explores its purpose and use in different contexts, highlighting examples from ongoing policy debates and initiatives. It will also discuss how digital self-determination relates to concepts such as digital autonomy, digital sovereignty, etc. The module seeks to create a working definition of concept and it’s dimensions or facets. |
| 3 | Contrastations: Digital Solidarity and Communality | In this module, we critically challenge the notion of “self-determination” and explore alternative or at least complementary perspectives that put more emphasis on solidarity and the social conditions of digital self-determination. The session seeks to deepen the shared understanding of the social context and conditions - and assumptions behind - any form of “self-determination.” It will also examine the role of shared and “trustworthy” data spaces as an example of how digital self-determination and larger societal goals can be aligned. |
| 4 | Participation and Self-Determination in the Digital Economy | While previous modules have focused on conceptual and horizontal issues, this module kicks-off a series of vertical explorations into different application areas of digital self- determination by examining what it means to be able to participate in the digital economy. The module highlights insights from youth and media research on creative expression and different forms of “capital”, and also addresses the relationship between digital citizenship skills and economic opportunity. |
| 5 | Digital Health and Well-Being | In this module, learners will approach and learn about the chances and challenges of digital self-determination in health from a multidisciplinary angle – technology, medicine, law and policy. From a technical perspective, learners will explore which problems in medicine can and cannot be solved with artificial intelligence (AI). Using the COVID tracing app as an example, the clinical utility of AI shall be explored from a medical perspective. Within a legal and policy analysis, learners will consider how individual and public interests can be balanced adequately in order to foster innovation while also protecting individual rights. |
| 6 | Information Diets | In this module, learners will engage with a major issue: the question how we can build an information ecosystem that allows for an information diet that supports the kind of informed choices digital self-determination hopes to enable. The module starts with a broad overview but then focus on the particular case of Wikipedia and open-access research. How do we both expand the knowledge that is available on the web while ensuring that the available content is not just from the institutions and communities with the most resources? |
| 7 | Trustworthy Data | This module takes a deep dive at an organization that is explore issues of digital self-determination with real-world effects. In particular, the module looks at how to acquire a social license for data reuse through co-determination of data responsibility frameworks and the questions that matter when pursuing this work. |
| 8 | Creativity and the Social Contract | In this module, we want to unleash the power of art, literature and imagery to imagine the Urban Social Contract of the future. As a backdrop we want to take the current and future space exploration and the possibility of establishing human settlements in other planets to creatively think about the urban/digital challenges that we would face in a city built outside Earth. Learners will hear from an expert in architecture and urbanism to learn how we used to think about the future of cities and the cities of the future and how city surveillance and power of control has evolved over time. |
| 9 | Reimagining Digital Self-Determination | This final module highlights the ideas and work that participants in the original research sprint engaged with during the two months it ran in Spring 2021. For learners, we hope this will prove a moment to reflect and consider how they have explored digital self-determination through various lenses (economics, health, media consumption) as well as challenged certain assumptions around the concept. In addition to reflecting on what ideas we have about digital self-determination, we encourage learners to offer recommendations about the key considerations around this subject. |
This project is the culmination of many different people's support, insight, and work.
Juan Diego Ardila, Angelica Balanta, Satchit Balsari, Brigitte Benoit-Landale, Alessio Bertolini, Beatriz Botero Arcila, Tiago Carneiro Peixoto, Bernardo Caycedo, Fiona Cece, Sidharth Chauhan, Yves Daccord, Nighat Dad, Roger Dubach, Lance Eaton, Stefan Feuerriegel, Christian Fieseler, Mark Findlay, Urs Gasser, Sarah Genner, Satdeep Gill, Isaac Johnson, Jenny Korn, Malavika Jayaram, Megan Kelleher, Danil Kerimi, Reubin Langevin, Christoph Lutz, Sabelo Mhlambi, Bryan Newbold, Andrea Owe, Lorrayne Porciuncula, Nydia Remolina Leon, Jaclyn Sawyer, Adrienne Schmoeker, Nishant Shah, Wolfgang Schulz, Lis Sylvan, Lokman Tsui, Santiago Uribe, Stefaan Verhulst, Kerstin Vokinger, Andrew Young
Karolina Alama-Maruta, Kawsar Ali, Rachid Benharrousse, Hei Yin Chan, Ana Margarida Coelho, Leonid Demidov, Maria Francesca De Tullio, Alexandra Giannopoulou, Tomás Guarna, Martyna Kalvaitytė, İdil Kula, Zachary Marcone, Derguene Mbaye, Hillary McLauchlin, Samreen Mushtaq , Areej Mawasi, Narayanamoorthy Nanditha, Carmen Ng, Oluwatimilehin Olagunju, Temitayo Olofinlua, Mary Rhauline Torres, Jean-Baptiste Scherrer, Eraldo Souza Dos Santos, Christian Thönnes, Constanza Vidal Bustamante
Special thanks go to the German Federal President and Stiftung Mercator for supporting the Network of Center's Ethics of Digitalisation initiative.
Just what is "digital self-determination"? Take a few minutes to consider what you think of when you hear that term. What examples come to mind? How does it exist? Where does it exist?
In this module, we take our first steps in exploring that question through three very different lenses highlighted by the speakers. By the end of this module, learners should have expanded some of their thinking and consideration about the concept.
Review the following before moving into the rest of this section:
These videos are not meant to comprehensively cover the topics. Instead, these videos are meant to spark a conversation about the ideas contained within. They often contain questions or different lenses from which to explore the week's topic. Viewers should look to the videos for ideas and from there, explore possible on their own, relevant research, videos, government documents, reports, etc that can further enhance their understanding.
| Speaker | Roger Dubach | Malavika Jayaram | Jenny Korn |
|---|---|---|---|
| Video | |||
| Video summaton | Roger Dubach reflects on how governments try to bring citizens’ active engagement to the digital world, and warns us of the risk of an understanding of digital self-determination that ends up locking us into a data-protected world. | Malavika Jayaram links the idea of self-determination to identity, how others perceive us, and the role of the other in the relational process of making meaning of ourselves and our agency in the digital realm. | Jenny Korn urges us to ask, “for whom does this digital self-determination benefit?” How do certain types of algorithms and other digital technologies represent and omit minority communities? How could we keep in mind our unknown unknowns during the research sprint, and what boundaries do they imply? |
Before the program started, we had participants make a 1-minute video discussing some of their thoughts on digital self-determination. As a follow up to engaging with the speakers above, we asked them to revisit their thoughts to create a new resource that furthers our understanding of digital self-determination based upon the videos above.
| Artifact | Author | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Mind Mapping Artifact | Karolina Alama-Maruta | An exhaustive mind map that captures the complexity of digital self-determination from its components to its definition |
| Karolina Alama-Maruta | This short video presents one of the approaches towards defining the concept of digital self-determination. | |
| Rachid Benharrousse | The digital space is already political and subject to dominant digital infrastructures. The Habermasian notion of Refeudalization is used to further the former idea. | |
| Ana Margarida Coelho | An infographic on how agents construct their external images and how the system is significantly beyond their control | |
| Leonid Demidov | This video explores digital self-determination on an individual level. | |
| Tomás Guarna | A brief text offers thoughts on the challenges of reaching a definition of digital self-determination and a promising path forward | |
| Zachary Marcone | One student's perspective on not losing sight of "self-determination" when attempting to forward "digital self-determination." | |
| Carmen Ng | A short video exploring digital self-determination through various personas and a visualization of some of the components of the concept | |
| Carmen Ng | A visualization of some of the components of the concept of digital self-determination. | |
| Timi Olagunju | This is a poetic rendition of an understanding of digital self determination for a lay, non-expert person. |
Based upon this introductory module, how might you update, enhance, or adjust your answer with one or more of these speaker’s ideas in mind--particularly, for new approaches to digital self-determination that you might not have considered or encountered previously?
Goal: To create an artifact that deepens the discussion of digital self-determination based upon this module.
Format: This artifact can be written, audio recording, video, or some other multimedia concept (card game, branching scenarios, collage, Prezi, etc).
Be as creative as you want with this but keep in mind that if you are making things, particularly visuals or integrating video/audio content from elsewhere that you make sure you have the legal permission to do so. Along those lines, using of Creative Common licensed materials or even materials from places like the Internet Archive.
Length/Duration: This is a bit tricky with different formats. For instance, the goal could be 300-500 words. Yet, that might be wildly over the mark if you are writing a poem or under the mark if you wrote out a script, but just perfect if you’re writing some reflections.
Instead of the ideal length, consider the audience. Think about how you would construct this response to someone that is new or interested in this subject. What might be a reasonably small but deep engagement with one or more of the questions provided by the speakers and the vantage points that your work could provide to such an audience.
If you are exploring this course on your own, we encourage you to create artifacts to share on Twitter or other social media platforms using the following hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination
Roger Dubach
Roger Dubach, born in 1974, studied Law at the University of Fribourg (Switzerland) and Philosophy at the University of Louvain-la-Neuve (Belgium). In 2003, he joined the diplomatic service of the Federal Department of Foreign Affairs and was appointed as a Diplomatic Advisor to the Director of the Federal Office for Energy in 2006. In this and his next function as Energy Counsellor at the Swiss Mission to the EU in Brussels, he acted as Technical Director of the energy negotiations between Switzerland and the EU. In 2013, he was appointed as a Personal Advisor to the Federal Councillor Doris Leuthard, and later as Deputy Director of the Task Force for the Swiss OSCE Chairmanship. Between 2016 and 2018, he served as Diplomatic Advisor on G7 and G20 issues in the Cabinet of the OECD Secretary-General in Paris, and was appointed by the Federal Council in August 2018 as an Ambassador and Deputy Director of the Directorate of International Law.
Malavika Jayaram
Malavika is the inaugural Executive Director of Digital Asia Hub, a Hong Kong-based independent research think-tank incubated by the Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society at Harvard University, where she is also a Faculty Associate. A technology lawyer for over 15 years, she practised law at Allen & Overy, London, and was Vice President and Technology Counsel at Citigroup. She was featured in the International Who’s Who of Internet e-Commerce & Data Protection Lawyers, and voted one of India’s leading lawyers. She taught India’s first course on Information Technology & Law in 1997, and has taught as adjunct faculty at Northwestern University’s Pritzker School of Law in Chicago. She is on the Advisory Boards of the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) and Mozilla’s Tech Policy Fellowship, and on the Executive Committee of the IEEE Global Initiative on Ethics of Autonomous and Intelligent Systems. Malavika is an Associate Fellow with Chatham House (the Royal Institute of International Affairs), as part of its Asia-Pacific Programme. She is also a member of the High-level Expert Advisory Group to the OECD project, “Going Digital: Making the Transformation Work for Growth and Well-being."
Jenny Korn
Founding Director of Princeton Diversity Discussions + Research Affiliate and the Founding Coordinator of the Race+Tech+Media Working Group at the Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society at Harvard University. Jenny Korn is a feminist activist of color for social justice, a ciswoman scholar of race and gender in mass media, digital life, and artificial intelligence, and a member of Mensa, the high intelligence quotient (IQ) society. Korn is a Research Affiliate and the Founding Coordinator of the Race+Tech+Media Working Group at the Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society at Harvard University. She is the Founding Director of Princeton Diversity Discussions, a free, public, ongoing series of in-person and virtual group gatherings to share personal opinions and lived experiences focused on race, racism, and racial justice that she founded seven years ago and now meets weekly across over twenty sites in the United States. The author of numerous publications, Korn has won awards from the Carl Couch Center for Social and Internet Research; the Association for Information Science and Technology; the Philosophy of Communication Division and the African American Communication and Culture Division of the National Communication Association; the Minorities and Communication Division and the Communication Theory and Methodology Division of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication; and the Organization for the Study of Communication, Language, and Gender. She has given over one hundred talks as invited keynote presentations, university guest lectures, interactive community education, and refereed conference presentations. As a public scholar, Korn has been quoted in interviews with NPR, CNN, SXSW, Bustle, Colorlines, Fox News, Forbes, Mashable, Reader’s Digest, U.S. News & World Report, Washington Post, and more. Drawing on critical race and intersectional feminist theories, Korn explores how Internet spaces and artificial intelligences influence, and are influenced, by assemblages of race and gender and how online producers-consumers have constructed inventive digital representations and computer-mediated communications of identity.
Source: Digital self-determination/Beginning Inquiries, revision 2285870 (CC BY-SA 4.0).
This module introduces the concept of digital-self determination and explores its purpose and use in different contexts, highlighting examples from ongoing policy debates and initiatives. It will also discuss how digital self-determination relates to concepts such as digital autonomy, digital sovereignty, etc. The module seeks to create a working definition of concept and it’s dimensions or facets.
These videos are not meant to comprehensively cover the topics. Instead, these videos are meant to spark a conversation about the ideas contained within. They often contain questions or different lenses from which to explore the week's topic. Viewers should look to the videos for ideas and from there, explore possible on their own, relevant research, videos, government documents, reports, etc that can further enhance their understanding.
| Speaker | Wolfgang Schulz | Mark Findlay | Nydia Remolina | Sabelo Mhlambi | Lorrayne Porciuncula & Bertrand De La Chapelle |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Video | |||||
| Video Summation | Wolfgang Schulz provides an overview of the concept of digital self-determination in its multifaceted complexity. Additionally, Prof. Schulz explains the significance of the German Federal Constitutional Court’s ‘Census’ Decision of 1983, in which the term “informational self-determination” was first used. | Mark Findlay & Nydia Remolina share their visionary approach to the self and the digital space that moves forward the research on digital self-determination beyond the existing paradigms of data property and data subjects toward an account centered on communal duties, responsibilities, and obligations | Sabelo Mhlambi - invites us to contemplate how the community enables self-autonomy, and the role of language and digital relationships in the continuous process of becoming a person by enriching other people’s lives and personhood. | Lorrayne Porciuncula & Bertrand De La Chapelle - help us historicize and reframe our conversation beyond the usual dichotomies we tend to use when theorizing on
data sovereignty and self-determination. | |
For this module, participants are asked to build out an annotated bibliography of works that would be useful in helping to further study and write about this topic. While there is the Digital Self-Determination bibliography in full, here are some of the highlights from that list.
| Citation | Description | Contributor |
|---|---|---|
| Bodó, B. (2020) “Mediated trust: A theoretical framework to address the trustworthiness of technological trust mediators”. New Media & Society 00(0), pp. 1-23. | This article introduces the new theoretical concept of technology-mediated trust to analyze the role of complex techno-social assemblages in trust production and distrust management | Alexandra Giannopoulou |
| Budd, B., Midzain-Gobin, L., Gabel, C., & Goodman, N. (2019). Digital Democracy and Self-Determination: Lessons from First Nations in Canada. Digitization & Challenges to Democracy. McMaster University: Institute on Globalisation and the Human Condition, pp. 14-18. | This article looks into the ways in which these tools [digital technologies] have shaped political mobilisation for the marginalised First Nations in Canada who have suffered through a long history of exclusion and disempowerment. | Samreen Mushtaq |
| Coleman, D. (2019) “Digital Colonialism: The 21st Century Scramble for Africa through the Extraction and Control of User Data and the Limitations of Data Protection Laws”. 24 MICH. J. RACE & L, pp. 417-439. | It raises the questions: what happens in a world where there are lean policies guiding data? By examining the data protection laws in Kenya, the author shows what needs to be done for a policy to protect its people. | Temitayo Olofinlua |
| Erichsen, L. & Prewitt, M. (2020). “Solving the Social Dilemma” and “The Data Freedom Act”. | The data coalition model proposed by the authors emphasizes the interpersonal/relational nature of data, and the need for models that move beyond individualistic conceptions of data ownership. | Constanza Vidal Bustamante |
| Mittelstadt, B. (2017). “From Individual to Group Privacy in Big Data Analytics”. Philos. Technol. (2017) 30, pp. 475-494. | While very fascinating, the article also addresses some of the very significant hurdles to a robust concept of group privacy, namely the instability of algorithmically created group identities. | Christian Thönnes |
For this module's activity, we want are looking to expand our understanding of digital self-determination. So when the program ran, we encouraged participants to seek out research and information about the topic. Since this is a never-ending task, we encourage people using this material to continue to contribute to our collected works.
Goal: To continue to develop the Digital Self-Determination bibliography by finding additional works on digital self-determination and providing citations and brief summaries about said research.
Format: Each contribution should include the following:
Here is an example of what that would look like when you add it to the page:
| Bozdag, E., & Van Den Hoven, J. (2015). Breaking the filter bubble: democracy and design. Ethics and information technology, 17(4), 249-265.
Type of Resource: Secondary Summary: The authors review different conceptions of democracy (liberal, deliberative, republican/contestatory, agonistic/inclusive) and the implications of “filter bubbles” (the reduced availability of divergent opinions/realities that we encounter online as a consequence of personalization algorithms) for each of them. They argue that the current set of tools and algorithms that tech designers have adopted to guard against filter bubbles reflect the values upheld by some models of democracy (e.g., liberal democracy’s emphasis on self-determination), but not all models of democracy (e.g., the agonistic model’s call for the inclusion of minorities in the public debate.) Contributor: Vidal Bustamante, Constanza |
Location: Please place any entry in the proper spot based on alphabetical order of the first author's last name.
Length: Add as many as you want but we typically looked for 3-5 contributions.
If you are exploring this course on your own, we encourage you to create artifacts to share on Twitter or other social media platforms using the following hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination
Sabelo Mhlambi
Sabelo Mhlambi is the founder of Bantucracy a public interest organization that focuses on ubuntu ethics and technology, a Technology & Human Rights Fellow at Carr Center for Human Rights Policy, and a Fellow at the Berkman-Klein Center for Internet & Society. Mhlambi's work is at the intersection of human rights, ethics, culture, and technology and emphasizes global south perspectives in AI policy.
In particular, Mr Mhlambi's research examines the human rights implications of algorithmic technology on marginalized communities and proposes a new ethical framework for governing the creation and use of Artificial Intelligence in ways that maximize social progress and harmony. Mhlambi's work broadens the conversation on Ethics and AI by introducing non-western frameworks for examining the effects automated decision making technology and has been used to advise African governments on Ethical AI policy. Mr Mhlambi's work is also supplemented by more than a decade building large scale software systems, which include Natural Language Processing for African languages, open-source anti-censorship software, and content recommendation systems.
Lorrayne Porciuncula
Lorrayne Porciuncula is the Director of the Data & Jurisdiction Program of the Internet & Jurisdiction Policy Network. Her professional and academic experience has been focused on issues around data, Internet governance, infrastructure regulation, and communication policy. Prior to joining the Internet & Jurisdiction Policy Network, she worked at the OECD (2014-2020) as the Strategic Advisor for Digital Economy Policy, coordinating issues related to data governance, artificial intelligence, and blockchain, and leading the production of several reports and country studies related to connectivity, infrastructure regulation, technology convergence, and inclusion.
Lorrayne has acted as the OECD focal point and speaker at high-level international meetings and fora such as the IGF, UN Broadband Commission for Sustainable Development (UN-BBCom), APT, UN-ESCAP, ECLAC, and EQUALS. Prior to the OECD, Lorrayne worked as an economist at the ITU, in the Secretariat of the UN-BBCom (2012-2014). Lorrayne is an affiliate to the Berkman Klein Center for Internet & Society at Harvard University, conducting research on data for development. She holds a Master's degree in Development Economics from the Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies (IHEID), Switzerland, and an International Relations bachelor's degree from the University of Brasilia (UnB), Brazil.
Wolfgang Schulz
Prof. Dr. Wolfgang Schulz is director of the Hans-Bredow-Institut for Media Research and has the university professorship "Media Law and Public Law including Theoretical Foundations” at the Faculty of Law at Universität Hamburg. In February 2012, he was also appointed director at Alexander von Humboldt Institute for Internet and Society in Berlin.
Wolfgang Schulz is a member of the Committee of Experts on Internet Intermediaries (MSI-NET) of the European Council and has been elected chairman thereof. He is also chairman of the expert committee “Information and Communication” and, thus, board member of the German Commission for UNESCO. Furthermore, he will serve on the advisory board of the Law & Technology Centre of Hong Kong University.
His work emphasises the freedom of communication, problems of legal regulation with regard to media contents, questions of law in new media, above all in digital television, and the legal bases of journalism, but also the jurisprudential bases of freedom of communication and the implications of the changing public sphere on law.
Nydia Remolina
Nydia Remolina is a Research Associate at the SMU Centre for AI and Data Governance and Adjunct Faculty at Singapore Management University. Her main areas of work and academic research include financial regulation, capital markets, banking law, fintech, digital ethics, AI governance, and the intersection of law and technology. She has taught or delivered lectures at several institutions in the United States, Asia, Europe, and Latin America. Nydia has been an instructor for the Global Certificate Program jointly organized by Harvard Law School and the International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) and has been invited to speak about fintech and financial regulation at various international organizations and regulators, such as the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS). Nydia has also acted as a Senior Advisor to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) and she worked at Sullivan & Cromwell’s New York Office. Nydia has a Master in the Science of Law (JSM) from Stanford University and has graduate studies in Economics, Finance and Computer Science from the International University of Andalusia.
Source: Digital self-determination/Digital Self-Determination- An Approximation, revision 2287043 (CC BY-SA 4.0).
In this module, we critically challenge the notion of “self-determination” and explore alternative or at least complementary perspectives that put more emphasis on solidarity and the social conditions of digital self-determination. The session seeks to deepen the shared understanding of the social context and conditions - and assumptions behind - any form of “self-determination.” It will also examine the role of shared and “trustworthy” data spaces as an example of how digital self-determination and larger societal goals can be aligned.
These videos are not meant to comprehensively cover the topics. Instead, these videos are meant to spark a conversation about the ideas contained within. They often contain questions or different lenses from which to explore the week's topic. Viewers should look to the videos for ideas and from there, explore possible on their own, relevant research, videos, government documents, reports, etc that can further enhance their understanding.
| Speaker | Megan Kelleher | Lokman Tsui | Nishant Shah |
|---|---|---|---|
| Video | |||
| Video Summary | Megan Kelleher - tells us about her research on indigenous knowledge systems in which all entities are interconnected, interdependent, and interrelational; the resulting ontologies do not place human at the center but configure a situated distributed network similar to a blockchain in which land is active, sacred, and the source of all knowledge. | Lokman Tsui - addresses the relationship between self-determination and survival with a biographical perspective that allows us all to reflect on how the tension between authenticity and survival takes place in Hong Kong, on the internet, and in ourselves. | Nishant Shah - begins by illustrating how family stories can influence how we interpret the factual value of photographs From there, he expands on his critique of the criteria we use to think about our digital selves and highlights the often unconfessed premise of a sovereign subject able to decide on their digital appearance vis-à-vis stringent technological systems. |
For this module's activity, we encouraged participants to engage in rapid prototyping based upon Nashant Shah’s talk. We asked them to 1) identify an informational life form, 2) find something that threatens its well-being, 3) imagine an intervention to minimize the condition of the threat, and 4) ensure that they were engaging in a politics of survival. Here are some of the participants’ creative artifacts.
| Artifact | Author | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Narayanamoorthy Nanditha | This is a narrative piece on regional Indian literature as an informational life form. This piece speaks specifically to how the Internet threatens the death of Tamil/regional literature owing to the monopoly of English on digital platforms, and the need to engage with the politics of its survival. | |
| Artifact (Prezi) | Hillary McLauchlin | This artifact shares a brief case study: “Emotions Under Siege. Emotion Recognition systems” |
| Rory Torres | This infographic considers how modern gaming technology and the pandemic have transformed how children play to the point of threatening Philippine traditional outdoor games -- and ironically, how modern gaming technology can also preserve it. | |
| Kyle Chan | This video illustrates the hazards that Cantonese faces today in Hong Kong and how blockchain could be the key to a politics of language survival. | |
| Areej Mawasi | This artifact considers the representation of language and usage of language within technologies as part of digital self-determination using "cat" meaning in spoken Arabic dialects as an example. | |
| İdil Kula | This artifact discusses educational progress data as a possible example for an informational life form and further examines what's the relationship between political survival and educational data while laying out potential risks and possible cures for them. | |
| Carmen Ng | A short video exploring the role of emotion data in shaping digital self-determination, particularly for children under classroom surveillance that deploys emotional recognition technologies. |
In this module, participants engaged in rapid prototyping that included the following based upon Nashant Shah's talk. Their process was as follows:
We would like you to do a similar activity and build it out in full as a narrative covering the points above.
Goal: To create a narrative piece around an informational life form.
Format: This activity can be written, audio recording, video, or some other multimedia concept (animation, branching scenarios, collage, Prezi, etc). We encourage the use of visuals to conceptualize it but those visuals can be simple (hand-drawn on notebook paper that you capture with your phone) or more complex--and obviously, no visuals if you are doing something written or in audio solely.
We encourage you to be as creative as you want with this but we also encourage that if you are making things, particularly visuals or integrating video/audio content from elsewhere that you make sure you have the legal permission to do so. Along those lines, we encourage the use of Creative Common licensed materials or even materials from places like the Internet Archive. Additionally, we ask that you do not use logos of Digital Asia Hub or Berkman Klein Center in the creation of your artifacts.
Length/Duration: This is a bit tricky with different formats. For instance, the goal could be 300-500 words. Yet, that might be wildly over the mark if you are writing a poem or under the mark if you wrote out a script, but just perfect if you’re writing some reflections.
Instead of the ideal length, consider the audience. Think about how you would construct this response to someone that is new or interested in this subject. What might be a reasonably small but deep engagement with one or more of the questions provided by the speakers and the vantage points that your work could provide to such an audience.
If you are exploring this course on your own, we encourage you to create artifacts to share on Twitter or other social media platforms using the following hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination
Megan Kelleher
Megan Kelleher is a PhD candidate and one of RMIT’s Vice Chancellor’s Indigenous Pre‑Doctoral Fellows in the School of Media and Communication. The title of her thesis is ‘Blockchain Mapping and Indigenous Knowledge Systems: Observations at the interface between distributed consensus technology and Indigenous governance’. Megan is investigating whether blockchain technology can interface with an Indigenous knowledge system – and conversely whether an Indigenous knowledge system can be used to guide the coordination of processes within a blockchain system. Grounded in her Barada/Baradha and Gabalbara/Kapalbara heritage, the research will be approached from an Indigenous standpoint, contributing to the field from an important Australian research perspective.
Nishant Shah
Nishant Shah is Director of Research & Outreach and Professor Aesthetics and Culture of Technologies, at ArtEZ University of the Arts, The Netherlands. Knowledge Partner for the global art-technology Digital Earth Fellowship. Faculty Associate 2020-21 at the Berkman Klein Centre for Internet & Society, Harvard University. Mentor on the Feminist Internet Research Network. His work is at the intersections of body, identity, digital technologies, artistic practice, and activism, with a specific focus on non-canonical geographies. His current interest is in thinking through questions of artificial intelligence, digital subjectivity, and misinformation towards building inclusive, diverse, resilient, and equitable societies. His new book Really Fake is out in Spring 2021 with University of Minnesota Press.
Lokman Tsui
Lokman Tsui is a scholar, activist, and currently an Assistant Professor at the School of Journalism and Communication of the Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK), where his research focuses on free expression, digital rights and internet policy. Lokman was formerly Google's Head of Free Expression in Asia and the Pacific (2011-14).
Source: Digital self-determination/Contrastations: Digital Solidarity and Communality, revision 2287038 (CC BY-SA 4.0).
While previous modules have focused on conceptual and horizontal issues, this module kicks-off a series of vertical explorations into different application areas of digital self- determination by examining what it means to be able to participate in the digital economy. The module highlights insights from youth and media research on creative expression and different forms of “capital”, and also addresses the relationship between digital citizenship skills and economic opportunity.
Pre-session Materials
These videos are not meant to comprehensively cover the topics. Instead, these videos are meant to spark a conversation about the ideas contained within. They often contain questions or different lenses from which to explore the week's topic. Viewers should look to the videos for ideas and from there, explore possible on their own, relevant research, videos, government documents, reports, etc that can further enhance their understanding.
| Speaker | Tiago Peixoto | Angelica Balanta | Alessio Bertolini |
|---|---|---|---|
| Video | |||
| Video Summary | Tiago Peixoto explains why it is crucial to examine public procurement —the government’s purchases of goods, services, and works— to evaluate the extent to which government’s good intentions translate into actions, whether they reflect collective self-determination, and how they can innovate and promote a more fair and inclusive digital economy. | Angelica Balanta describes her path to recover an untold part of Colombian history, namely the often-overlooked past of African enslavement and colonization. Miss Balanta - her digital entrepreneur alter ego - uses the traditional turban and her blog as tools for resistance and reappropriation of African roots. | Alessio Bertolini summarizes the mainstream narrative that online platforms of the ‘gig economy’ use to promote their supposedly autonomous, flexible, and easy working conditions for “partners” and how The Fairwork Project scores such conditions and lobbies for better ones. |
For this module's activity, learners were encouraged choose among the following options: 1.) create a global, regional or national map of the Digital Economy, 2.) record a podcast episode about the Digital Economy, 3.) write a one-page case study of a gig or sharing economy platform/company that operates in their country, or 4.) make a video tutorial on a topic or hobby that they are passionate about and reflect on the digital skills they used in making it. Below are samples of learners' artifacts.
| Artifact | Author | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Carmen Ng | This podcast episode explores how a 60-year-old bookbinding and letter printing studio in Kyoto has found a way to leverage the digital economy for immersive experiences. | |
| Rory Torres | This podcast features co-owners and co-chefs of Kitchen 402, a newly created cooking and delivering service for homemade gourmet Filipino food, born during the height of the pandemic. It explores the role of digital technology, including the gig economy, the pandemic, and entrepreneurship have helped this business thrive in the past year. | |
| Constanza M. Vidal Bustamante | Case study on Chilean-created grocery delivery app Cornerstore | |
| Narayanamoorthy Nanditha | This piece explores the gig sharing economy in India with a focus on the rideshare company, Ola, its services, business model, worker participation, and the impact of the gig work on workers. | |
| Jean-Baptiste Scherrer | Digitalization of an actor | |
| Areej Mawasi | In this artifact I interviewed a Palestinian digital artist, called Ameer Basheer who described how he used digital media as an artist. | |
| Unnamed Participant | A case study on ZenJob | |
| Maria Francesca De Tullio | An interview with Ana Sofia Acosta Alvarado on digital economy and the project TAPAS (There Are Platforms as Alternatives) | |
| İdil Kula | This artifact is a case study on the business practice of a platform, Getir. | |
| Hillary McLauchlin | This artifact, a case study of the grocery shopping platform Instacart, investigates the app's business model, reliance on gig workers, and actions taken by the platform's shoppers to make their voices heard in the digital food delivery economy. This artifact contrasts the language used to advertise Instacart with the reality of its impact on workers. | |
| Eraldo | This one-page case study discusses OnlyFans' role in the Brazilian gig economy. It shows that although OnlyFans makes self-determination possible for many content creators, especially for sex workers, it also creates new forms of dependence and precariousness in the lives of many of them. | |
| Temitayo Olofinlua | An exploration of the book market in Nigeria and digitalization. |
For this module, learners were given to option to choose an activity from among the following:
Learners are encouraged to look for region-specific platforms or localized and distinct use of digital tools to establish, maintain, expand a particular digital economy or economic practices.
If you are exploring this course on your own, we encourage you to create artifacts to share on Twitter or other social media platforms using the following hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination
Miss Balanta
Miss Balanta is the online alter-ego of Angelica Balanta, Colombian graphic and fashion designer, blogger, influencer, photographer, agent and model. Miss Balanta project was born spontaneously in 2013: Growing up seeing Afro-Colombian women wear turbans and head pieces inspired Angelica to launch a fashion blog and make video tutorials on how to wear and style Afro Colombian culture headpieces. Her videos have been watched over 170.000 times on YouTube and her IG account has over 60.000 followers. Miss Balanta is fueled by Angelica's curiosity to learn more about her Afro roots and transform items of Black culture into fashionable works of art. With her online presence and original designs Miss Balanta seeks to empower women, educate, and highlight the values of Afro culture.
Alessio Bertolini
Alessio Bertolini is a Researcher at the Oxford Internet Institute for the project FairWork, where he is investigating platform work in the UK and Germany. Before joining the OII, Alessio was a postdoctoral researcher of the project ‘Work Demand: Contracting for Work in a Changing Economy’ (https://workondemand.co.uk/) headed by Prof. Ruth Dukes at the University of Glasgow. Within the broader project, Alessio had been investigating ideas and strategies used by different stakeholders and policy actors in the regulation of the platform economy in a comparative perspective. Before joining the Work on Demand team, Alessio completed his PhD in Social Policy at the University of Edinburgh on the topic of comparative labour market regulations for non-standard workers in Italy and the UK. With a background in economics and policy studies, his area of expertise involves employment and welfare rights for non-standard workers from a comparative European perspective. More broadly, his research and teaching interests include labour markets and social security policies and regulations. Both before and during his PhD, he was involved in several national and international research projects on the topic of labour market and welfare policies.
Tiago Peixoto
Tiago is a Senior Public Sector Specialist at the World Bank’s Governance Global Practice. Having joined the Bank in 2010, Tiago’s activities focus on working with governments to develop solutions for better public policies and services. Prior to joining the World Bank, Tiago has managed projects and consulted for a number of organizations, such as the European Commission, OECD, United Nations, Bertelsmann Foundation, and the Brazilian and UK governments. Formerly a research coordinator for the Electronic Democracy Centre at the University of Zurich, Tiago is currently a faculty member of New York University’s Governance Lab. A board member for Our Cities Network and Intelligent Digital Avatars, he also sits in the advisory boards of a number of organizations such as The Participatory Budgeting Project and Our City Thoughts. Featured in TechCrunch as one of the “20 Most Innovative People in Democracy”, Tiago holds a PhD and a Masters in Political Science from the European University Institute, as well as a Masters in Organized Collective Action from Sciences-Po Paris. He blogs at DemocracySpot and tweets at @participatory.
Source: Digital self-determination/Participation and Self-Determination in the Digital Economy, revision 2318181 (CC BY-SA 4.0).
In this module, learners will approach and learn about the chances and challenges of digital self-determination in health from a multidisciplinary angle – technology, medicine, law and policy. From a technical perspective, learners will explore which problems in medicine can and cannot be solved with artificial intelligence (AI). Using the COVID tracing app as an example, the clinical utility of AI shall be explored from a medical perspective. Within a legal and policy analysis, learners will consider how individual and public interests can be balanced adequately in order to foster innovation while also protecting individual rights.
For this session, videos were not recorded but we share with you the summation of the speakers' talks and would encourage folks to use these as starting points to find additional video or audio content that explores these issues. A good example are the writings, videos, and other materials by the Berkman Klein Center on Internet and Society's Digital Pandemic Response program.
| Speaker | Stefan Feuerriegel | Satchit Balsari | Kerstin N Vokinger |
|---|---|---|---|
| Video Summary | Stefan Feuerriegel focuses on the possible applications of AI in the context of health and well-being. Although various digital solutions have already been implemented, deployments requiring higher levels of complexity and customization still pose a significant challenge for machine learning. In novel circumstances where modest quantities of data are available, AI fails. It appears that navigating in the meanders of multi-dimensional discussions and deciphering varieties of inconclusive feedback is still a human-centered domain. (Summarized by Karolina Alama-Maruta) | Satchit Balsari illustrates the clinical utility of AI through the emergence of COVID-19 tracking apps in the initial phase of the pandemic. He draws out a comparison between the three contact tracing apps which are deployed in different geographies - Germany, Singapore and India - and examines the tension between epidemiological utility and the degree of privacy invasion by discussing the role of decentralization. He then sheds light into the design choices and the context in which the apps are implemented by taking into consideration the fact that real life conditions often debunk the assumption of ‘technology always works’. Pointing out the private companies’ eagerness to be involved in the development processes for Covid-19 tracking apps and potential misuses, he argues the public healthcare sector shouldn’t be a safe haven for both start-ups with a bunch of opportunities to exploit data and governments to satisfy their surveillance needs on communities. (Summarized by İdil Kula) | Kerstin N Vokinger addresses the legal challenges of AI and self-determination emphasizing that while AI-based medical apps have increased, the definition of health data remains murky. “What’s most important is the context,” e.g. a person's mobility record could also be seen as health data. Such unclear parameters of health data complicate the legal discussions about privacy regulation and data access, particularly during a crisis. One example would be the evolving tension between individual interest for privacy and public interest in contact tracing during the COVID-19 pandemic. (Summarized by Carmen Ng) |
For this week’s artifacts, we asked participants to find a current example that illustrate some of the questions, challenges, or elements discussed in the session as relates to digital self-determination and the intersection of technology, medicine, policy and law in their country, region, state, or city and write a brief case study.
| Artifact | Author | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Christian Thönnes | An analysis of what can be learned from the German debate around contact tracing apps | |
| Ana Margarida Coelho | An audio recording explaining what the Portuguese app STAYAWAYCOVID is and how it played a role on the public health context. | |
| Constanza M. Vidal Bustamante | Case study on CoronApp, the Chilean government's official COVID-19 app | |
| Eraldo | In April 2018, BuzzFeed published an article denouncing the ways in which Grindr, a dating app for LGBT+ people, has shared its users' HIV information with third parties. This "five-minute case study" shows how the LGBT+ community has sought to protect its health data either by boycotting the app, filing complaints or lawsuits against the companies behind it, or calling for legal change. | |
| Hillary McLauchlin | This artifact, a poster with graphics entitled "Direct-to-Consumer: The Future of Mental Healthcare?" explores the challenges and opportunities presented by consumer mobile applications claiming to improve or treat mental health concerns. This artifact touches upon limitations in the current oversight of such apps and their quality, raising questions about the degree to which such technologies both empower––and undermine––patients' digital self-determination. | |
| Leonid Demidov | This short essay explores the question of data ownership from the digital agriculture point of veiw. | |
| Rachid Benharrousse | Wiqaytna as an app which has attempted to reduce COVID-19 cases in Morocco, but has been a means of collecting data, similar to the app on which it was based. | |
| Rory Torres | This brief case study on reach52's Online Health Check that uses Facebook Chatbot explores issues and asks questions on the app's privacy, quality, and how it can enhance digital self-determination in the health sector. | |
| Samreen Mushtaq | Brings forth the intersection of medicine, tropes of care, and surveillance through the case of Aarogya Setu app in India | |
| Tomás Guarna | A data ecosystem of a COVID test, repesenting the data flows and the tensions that underlie it. | |
| Kyle Chan | A mind map on the HK government COVID tracking app: Leave Home Safe |
For this module's activity, learners looked for an interesting current example of some of the questions, challenges, or elements discussed in this module in relation to digital self-determination at the intersection of technology, medicine, policy and law in their country, region, state, or city.
Goal: Conduct some research on the intersection of technology, medicine, and policy in your country or region, and produce an artifact that addresses or raises some of the questions and concerns from this module in relation to digital self-determination. Ideally, these will be case studies that will highlight what is happening, what are some of the challenges and solutions possible in the situation, and what are some of the additional questions raised through the lens of digital self-determination. Ideally, the artifact would include a set of questions to push the audience to think more deeply about the example or to compare it/connect it to other examples (e.g. “What could be changed to enhance the peoples/communities’ abilities to take more control of their health data?”)
Format: This activity can be written, audio recording, video, or some other multimedia concept (animation, branching scenarios, collage, Prezi, etc). We encourage the use of visuals to conceptualize it but those visuals can be simple (hand-drawn on notebook paper that you capture with your phone) or more complex--and obviously, no visuals if you are doing something written or in audio solely.
We encourage you to be as creative as you want with this but we also encourage that if you are making things, particularly visuals or integrating video/audio content from elsewhere that you make sure you have the legal permission to do so. Along those lines, we encourage the use of Creative Common licensed materials or even materials from places like the Internet Archive. Additionally, we ask that you do not use logos of Digital Asia Hub or Berkman Klein Center in the creation of your artifacts.
If you are exploring this course on your own, we encourage you to create artifacts to share on Twitter or other social media platforms using the following hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination
Satchit Balsari
Dr. Satchit Balsari is a Professor in emergency medicine at Harvard Medical School and Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center. Since 2009, he has been affiliated with the FXB Center for Health and Human Rights at Harvard University, where his research has contributed to advocacy on behalf of vulnerable populations affected by disasters and humanitarian crises. His interdisciplinary interests in mobile technology, disaster response, and population health have been informed by his clinical practice in the United States and his field work around the world. His research has resulted in innovative applications of mobile, cloud-based technology to address public health challenges in mass gatherings, disasters, and humanitarian crises. Dr. Balsari received his medical degree from Grant Medical College in Mumbai, India and his public health degree from Harvard; he completed his emergency medicine residency at Columbia and Cornell’s New York-Presbyterian Hospital. In March 2017, he was awarded the Dr B.C. Roy National Award by the President of India, for “outstanding services in the field of sociomedical relief.” Dr. Balsari is an Aspen Ideas Scholar, and Asia 21 Young Leader at the Asia Society.
Stefan Feuerriegel
Stefan is a Professor of management information systems in the Department of Management, Technology, and Economics at ETH Zurich. His group develops, implements, and evaluates new Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools to solve real-world challenges and to make a profound impact in our daily lives. Examples include AI tools for monitoring the COVID-19 epidemic, for managing global development aid flows, for identifying and mitigating fake news, and for effectively detecting health risks in diabetes patients. In his research, Stefan partnered with global industry players such as Foursquare, Thomson Reuters, ABB Hitachi, or Siemens to bring AI into practice. Stefan has further been an advisor of the SDG Financing Lab of the OECD, and a member of a COVID-19 working group of the World Health Organization (WHO). After obtaining a PhD from the University of Freiburg, he was a strategy consultant with McKinsey, and a visitor at Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh; the University of Texas at Austin; the University of New South Wales, Sydney; and the National Institute of Informatics, Tokyo.
Kerstin N Vokinger
Kerstin N Vokinger is a Professor at the University of Zurich, Faculty Associate at the Berkman Klein Center (Harvard University), and Affiliated Faculty at Harvard Medical School (Program on Regulation, Therapeutics, and Law). In her research, she focuses with her team on interdisciplinary questions at the intersection of law, medicine, and technology, with the goal to improve access to medicine and technology. In her areas of expertise, she also advises governmental authorities and international organizations. Kerstin studied in parallel law (JD) and medicine (MD), and conducted a PhD at the University of Zurich. She also completed a Masters of Law (LLM) at Harvard Law School, was a Visiting Fellow at the Berkman Klein Center, and a Postdoc Fellow at Harvard Medical School.
Source: Digital self-determination/Digital Health and Well-Being, revision 2285876 (CC BY-SA 4.0).
In this module, learners will engage with a major issue: the question how we can build an information ecosystem that allows for an information diet that supports the kind of informed choices digital self-determination hopes to enable. The module starts with a broad overview but then focus on the particular case of Wikipedia and open-access research. How do we both expand the knowledge that is available on the web while ensuring that the available content is not just from the institutions and communities with the most resources?
Read
Watch
Do
These videos are not meant to comprehensively cover the topics. Instead, these videos are meant to spark a conversation about the ideas contained within. They often contain questions or different lenses from which to explore the week's topic. Viewers should look to the videos for ideas and from there, explore possible on their own, relevant research, videos, government documents, reports, etc that can further enhance their understanding.
| Speaker | Sarah Genner | Isaac Johnson | Bryan Newbold | Satdeep Gill |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Video | ||||
| Video Summary | Sarah Genner offers a broad overview of the complex issues one should consider in evaluating how healthy is one’s information diet. Starting from various uses of “information”, this talk explores conceptual attempts to account for digital phenomena such as information economy, “infodemic” and presents Laswell’s Model of communication as a way to assess the information overload we frequently receive. The talk also maps alternative ways to relate with digital technologies such as “calm technology”, “digital detox”, “share mindfully”, “slow media”, and other ways to reclaim our attention and defend ourselves from surveillance. | Isaac Johnson introduces open knowledge initiatives and the tensions that inevitably arise from their fragile balance between quantity and quality of information. | Bryan Newbold talks about the work of Archive.org in keeping an open record of the Internet. Bryan briefly explains the ongoing transformation of the scholarly publication sector and how large academic publishers seem to have found a new way to dominate the field despite the rise of open access publications. These new dynamics in producing, keeping, and distributing academic knowledge compel us to reflect on who is and who should be responsible for keeping “the common” of the scholarly record. | Satdeep Gill recounts the story of Wikipedia in Punjabi, how it started by translating articles from English and how it quickly transformed into a fast-growing body of knowledge that includes digitized texts in Panjabi language that are in the public domain. Satdeep asks what would be the perfect balance for the Punjabi Wikimedia community between translating articles from other languages and going through the troubles of digitizing Punjabi texts. |
This week’s activity consisted of a critical assessment of a Wikipedia entry by examining it in its encyclopedic context (e.g. the same entry in different languages and other linked entries), the sources cited, whether it adheres to a neutral point of view, what other voices and references were left out, and more
| Artifact | Author | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Anonymous | This piece provides an assessment on the Wikipedia page - Citizenship Amendment Act (2019), and focuses on effective ways of decolonizing knowledge through the exploration of the perspectives, languages, and sources employed in the Wiki. | |
| Eraldo | This infographic offers an analysis of the ways in which the viewpoints of contemporary activists—namely, Black Lives Matter activists in the U.S., pro-democracy activists in Hong Kong, and members of the Civil Disobedience Movement in Myanmar—have been left out from the English-language Wikipedia entry on civil disobedience. | |
| Zachary Marcone | Analyzing the Wikipedia pages in different languages for China's digital currency, the digital yuan. | |
| Karolina Alama-Maruta | An exploration of the 2020-2021 Women's Strike protests in Poland entry on Wikipedia. | |
| Kawsar Ali | An assessment of the Christchurch Shooting Wikipedia Page. | |
| Tomás Guarna | An examination of Misinformation Wikipedia entries and their translations. | |
| Carmen Ng | A critique of the Wikipedia entry, "‘regulation of artificial intelligence". |
This is a two-part activity: a small exploration prior to the start of the module and then a deeper investigation and creation of an artifact following the session. The overall goal is to select a topic on Wikipedia with which you have some familiarity and summarize what knowledge sources are included and what steps would be taken to decolonize this topic.
Part I (Do before delving into the videos)
Part II (Do after exploring the videos and other artifacts)
Logistics
If you are exploring this course on your own, we encourage you to create artifacts to share on Twitter or other social media platforms using the following hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination
Sarah Genner is a media and internet scholar and lecturer at various universities in Switzerland and a visiting scholar at the Collegium Helveticum, co-sponsored by ETH Zurich, the University of Zurich, and the Zurich University of the Arts. Her research focuses on societal and psychological effects of the digital transformation. She is the author of numerous publications. She studied in Zurich and Berlin. After working as a teacher, journalist, and consultant, she was an associate researcher and lecturer at Zurich University of Applied Sciences from 2010 to 2018 focusing on digital media and the future of work. From 2014 to 2015, she was a visiting scholar and SNSF fellow at Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society at Harvard University. Her dissertation “ON/OFF – Risks and Rewards of the Anytime-Anywhere Internet” won the Mercator Award by the University of Zurich.
Bryan Newbold is a software developer and leads the Internet Archive's efforts to preserve and provide universal access to open research content. He has a background building scientific instruments, operating undersea robots, and contributing to peer-to-peer "dweb" network protocols. 2020-2021 Coronavirus quarantine has been spent in a group house in Seattle, WA, watching bamboo grow and cooking a different meal every night for a year.
Satdeep Gill is a Program Officer under the Community Programs team within the Wikimedia Foundation. In his role, Satdeep connects cultural institutions, including museums, archives, and libraries, with Wikimedia projects to further expand access to free knowledge globally. His work specifically focuses on leveraging Wikisource (Wikimedia’s free digital ebook library) to grow content in underrepresented languages online and connect cultural institutions to the Wikisource infrastructure to share their collections online. Satdeep is a longtime volunteer editor, contributing primarily to Punjabi Wikipedia and Punjabi Wikisource. He began working at the Wikimedia Foundation in 2017. Isaac Johnson is a research scientist with the Wikimedia Foundation. He has been conducting research on geographic inequities in digital knowledge since 2014 with a specific focus on Wikipedia and its sister projects since 2018. Through his work, he seeks to understand the barriers that marginalized communities face in securing representation online, build tools that demonstrate these challenges, and design interventions to ensure that they are not replicated via algorithmic systems.
Source: Digital self-determination/Information Diets, revision 2721487 (CC BY-SA 4.0).
This module takes a deep dive at an organization that is explore issues of digital self-determination with real-world effects. In particular, the module looks at how to acquire a social license for data reuse through co-determination of data responsibility frameworks and the questions that matter when pursuing this work.
We live in a world characterized by increased complexity. From climate change, to global pandemics, to rising and systematic inequality, there is a sense that old solutions to public problems are no longer sufficient.
The work of the Data Program at the GovLab at New York University Tandon School of Engineering begins from the premise that innovation in data collaboration, stewardship, and re-use can help address some of these problems. A wide body of evidence has irrefutably established that data can help improve our understanding of the world, tease out the root causes of various phenomena, forecast future conditions and opportunities, and evaluate and iterate on potential solutions.
Yet current practice in data re-use in the public interest is misaligned with public perceptions, not targeted at the questions that would be transformative if answered, and undertaken in the absence of a clear social license.
This module will explore new ways to engage people in co-determining:
These videos are not meant to comprehensively cover the topics. Instead, these videos are meant to spark a conversation about the ideas contained within. They often contain questions or different lenses from which to explore the week's topic. Viewers should look to the videos for ideas and from there, explore possible on their own, relevant research, videos, government documents, reports, etc that can further enhance their understanding.
| Speaker | Stefaan G. Verhulst | Andrew Young | Adrienne Schmoeker | Jaclyn Sawyer | Fiona Cece |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Video | |||||
| Video Summary | Stefaan G. Verhulst presents the GovLab and its goal of finding new ways of bringing together two key assets, people and data, to identify key social concerns and issues, propose cross-cutting recommendations, and co-design frameworks for responsible and legitimate re-uses of data compatible with people’s expectations. In the talk, Stefaan explains the importance of co-determining both the frameworks to get a social license for data re-use and the questions that are addressed using such data. Additionally, he briefly maps multiple paths that lead from data to insights when data holders and problem owners engage in participatory, co-determining processes. | Andrew Young tells us about The Data Assembly project, “a collaboration among and between citizens, civil rights organizations, key data holders and policymakers,” that started in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 in New York City. The Data Assembly took place through a series of deliberations of three mini-publics: a group of stakeholders with experience in the practice and policies around data use and re-use; a group of civic rights and advocacy organizations (e.g., Data For Black Lives); a diverse sample of New York residents. These deliberations were structured by three “exhibits” about mobility data analysis, aggregated consumer data, and 311 data. The key output of this collaborative, deliberative work is the Responsible Data Re-Use Framework. | Adrienne Schmoeker shares her experience leading the New York City Mayor's Office of Data Analytics team, as Deputy Chief Analytics Officer. In this brief talk, she reflects on the importance of The Data Assembly in the context of the COVID-19 emergency, in which many parties were interested in getting accurate information, analyzing it, and operationalizing it quickly for the benefit of close to nine million people. Adrienne highlights the benefits of developing data partnerships, for instance, by bringing together non-city data and city analysts. | Jaclyn Sawyer reflects on the benefits of The Data Assembly and data re-use in managing the COVID-19 crisis. From her perspective as the Director of Data Services and Program Analytics at Breaking Ground, a non-profit organization that provides a spectrum of homeless outreach and housing services in New York City. Jaclyn guides us through a five-year collective process of increasing systematization and understanding of the value of the “small data” the organization collects and uses, the importance of interdisciplinarity, and the evolving meaning of data literacy in this process. | Fiona Cece presents The 100 Questions Initiative, a collaborative attempt to find out the most transformative questions that can and should be answered by data and data collaboration in specific contexts. This global effort connects hundreds of “bilinguals” (experts with domain expertise and data science knowledge) to identify, source, and cluster questions on the subjects of migration, gender, air quality, the future of work, disinformation, governance, and food systems sustainability. The methodology uses online voting by the bilinguals and the larger public for the prioritization of the questions. |
In the original sprint, we did not have new artifacts to build for this week but we encourage you, especially if you have been going through each of the modules, at this point to start to think about what you might contribute to the discussion on Digital Self-Determination. This can be done in several ways. You could add artifacts to some of these modules or you could edit the Wikipedia entry on Digital Self-Determination that the Digital Asia Hub and Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society's Spring 2021 Research Sprint helped to create. You can also engage in conversation with other folks on the topics in general or by using the hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination.
Regardless of what you do, be sure to share on Twitter or other social media platforms using the following hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination
Stefaan G. Verhulst
Stefaan G. Verhulst is Co-Founder and Chief Research and Development Officer of the Governance Laboratory (The GovLab) at New York University (NYU), an action research center focused on improving governance using advances in science and technology - including data and collective intelligence. He is also, among other positions and affiliations, the Editor-in-Chief of Data & Policy, an open access journal by Cambridge University Press; the research director of the MacArthur Research Network on Opening Governance; Chair of the Data for Children Collaborative with Unicef; and a member of the High-Level Expert Group to the European Commission on Business-to-Government Data Sharing. In 2018 he was recognized as one of the 10 Most Influential Academics in Digital Government globally (as part of the Top 100 in Digital Government) by the global policy platform Apolitical.
Before joining NYU full time, Verhulst spent more than a decade as Chief of Research for the Markle Foundation, where he continues to serve as Senior Advisor. Previously at Oxford University he was the UNESCO Chairholder in Communications Law and Policy for the UK where he co-founded and was the Head of the Program in Comparative Media Law and Policy, He was a Senior Research Fellow at the Center for Socio Legal Studies and the Socio Legal Fellow of Wolfson College, and is still an emeritus fellow at Oxford. He also taught several years at the London School of Economics; and was Founder and Co-Director of the International Media and Info-Comms Policy and Law Studies (IMPS) at the University of Glasgow School of Law.
He has published widely - including seven books- and is asked regularly to present at international conferences including TED. Numerous organizations have sought his counsel - including the WorldBank; IDB, USAID, DFID, IDRC, AFP, the European Commission, Council of Europe, the World Economic Forum, UNICEF, OECD, Un-OCHA, UNDP and several other international bodies.
Andrew Young
Andrew Young is the Knowledge Director at The GovLab, where he leads research efforts focusing on the impact of technology on public institutions. Among the grant-funded projects he has directed are a global assessment of the impact of open government data; the development of a principles and practices for the responsible handling of data for and about children by humanitarian and development organizations; comparative benchmarking of government innovation efforts against those of other countries; a methodology for leveraging corporate data to benefit the public good; and crafting the experimental design for testing the adoption of technology innovations in federal agencies. Andrew has authored or co-authored a number of extended works on new approaches for improving governance with technology, including the books The Global Impact of Open Data and Open Data in Developing Economies.
Fiona Cece
Fiona Cece is a Research Fellow at The GovLab and the Project Lead for The 100 Questions Initiative. At GovLab, she has also contributed to the Open Data Policy Lab’s inaugural Data Stewardship Course, among other projects that seek to leverage data and technology for public value. Prior to joining GovLab, Fiona worked in the Executive Office of the Secretary-General at the United Nations, where she helped support decision-making fora and provide country-level policy analyses for the Executive and Deputy Committee levels. Additionally, she has provided research support to The Economist Intelligence Unit for a project regarding digital well-being policies in the Middle East and North Africa region and editorial support to the Journal of Public Policy. She holds a B.A. in Economics from Barnard College and a M.Sc. in Politics and Policy Analysis from Bocconi University in Milan, Italy.
Jaclyn Sawyer
Jaclyn Sawyer is a community data specialist, currently serving as the Director of Data Services and Program Analytics at Breaking Ground, an organization that provides a spectrum of homeless outreach and housing services in New York City. In this capacity, she built and leads an interdisciplinary data team of technologists and social workers that develop software and conduct analysis, led by Design Justice principles. She lectures at Columbia University where she co-developed an emerging tech and society course for social workers to bring the missing voices into data practice and reimagine the future of work. She is deeply invested in community built and supported internet and technology projects.
Adrienne Schmoeker
Adrienne Schmoeker is the former Deputy Chief Analytics Officer for the City of New York. During her tenure with the City of New York she led the team at the NYC Mayor's Office of Data Analytics, grew the NYC Open Data Program, co-founded NYC Open Data Week and was part of the founding team in the inaugural NYC CTO's Office. Adrienne is currently advising urban tech startups, helping design data programs and consulting on government technology programs.
Source: Digital self-determination/Trustworthy Data, revision 2287029 (CC BY-SA 4.0).
In this module, we want to unleash the power of art, literature and imagery to imagine the Urban Social Contract of the future. As a backdrop we want to take the current and future space exploration and the possibility of establishing human settlements in other planets to creatively think about the urban/digital challenges that we would face in a city built outside Earth. Learners will hear from an expert in architecture and urbanism to learn how we used to think about the future of cities and the cities of the future and how city surveillance and power of control has evolved over time. Learners will also hear from an ecological and space ethicist concerned about the moral and ethical frameworks of space exploration and multiplanetary terrestrial life.
Towards a new shore
Many light years away in space
There I will wait for you
Where human feet have never trodden
Where human eyes have never gazed
I will build a world of abstract dreams
And I’ll wait
In the realm of tomorrow
We will take the helm
Of a new ship
As the crack of a whip
We will suddenly be on the road
And traveling at the speed of light
Towards a new shore
The UN predicts that by 2050, around 68% of the world's population will live in urban areas. At the same time, we are experiencing a rapid digital transformation where the adoption of digital technologies are transforming all aspects of our lives from education, labor, our relation to Government and the exercise of our fundamental rights. Privacy, digital inequality, data governance and the increased power of Tech Companies are some of the issues that arise as a result of the digital transformation. These two forces (digitization and urbanization) and the structural changes and challenges they represent converge in the City. Cities are diverse places, where social and economic problems are most palpable. Trust in City Institutions remain high and they are at times better equipped to deal with policy issues where National Politics fails. In other words, the City is where ‘the rubber meets the road’ in terms of policy given that “social and political issues should be dealt with at the most immediate level consistent with their most adequate resolution.”
Moreover, these transformations affect core elements of our urban social contract; a Citys’ duty to guarantee security to its citizens. Governments, cities, and the private sector have turned to digital, biometric and physical surveillance of its citizens in the name of national and metropolitan security. We believe that to face these challenges we must redraw our Urban Social Contract and critically rethink our relationship with our cities and digital technologies.
In this session we want to unleash the power of art, literature and imagery to imagine the Urban Social Contract of the future. As a backdrop we want to take the current and future space exploration and the possibility of establishing human settlements in other planets to creatively think about the urban/digital challenges that we would face in a city built outside Earth. We will hear from an expert in architecture and urbanism to learn how we used to think about the future of cities and the cities of the future and how city surveillance and power of control has evolved over time. We will then hear from an ecological and space ethicist concerned about the moral and ethical frameworks of space exploration and multiplanetary terrestrial life.
Additional Recommended Materials
These videos are not meant to comprehensively cover the topics. Instead, these videos are meant to spark a conversation about the ideas contained within. They often contain questions or different lenses from which to explore the week's topic. Viewers should look to the videos for ideas and from there, explore possible on their own, relevant research, videos, government documents, reports, etc that can further enhance their understanding.
| Speaker | Beatriz Botero and Yves Daccord | Juan Diego Ardila | Andrea Owe |
|---|---|---|---|
| Video | |||
| Video Summary | Beatriz Botero and Yves Daccord, two founding members of the Edgelands Institute elaborate on the mission of their institute as well as set the stage for the succeeding discussion. (8:23) [link] | Juan Diego Ardila takes us on a journey through countless representations of cities across time. In this talk, titled “What the future city says about us”, Juan Diego’s architectural perspective allows us to reflect on various possible relationships between cities and buildings. This visual approach to cities pays attention to in-between spaces, open and closed areas, and the interaction between the parts and the whole of the complex socio-technical systems we have inhabited in the past, we live in today, and we will build tomorrow. Through a comprehensive review of past imaginaries of “the future city”, this talk is an excellent input for our dialogue on the structures of inequality and exclusion we have inherited from the past and are in place today in our cities. (25:17) [link] | Andrea Owe offers a perspective on life and flourishing off Earth from global catastrophic risk and environmental ethics. Andrea helps us critically reflect on the moral basis for new social contracts for humanity in space settlements. This talk urges us to imagine ways to safeguard the human species and the entire ecosphere that makes possible life on Earth. What moral values and knowledge should we bring with us to space habitats? How does the perspective of future life in space shed new light on the long-term sustainability and convenience of our current ways of life? Andrea suggests that space settlements might end up having more in common with indigenous ways of life than with todays’ urban lives. (13:43) [link] |
Learners took part in the “Red Skies Project”, a collective role-playing intellectual experiment focused on revising the social contract for an imaginary human settlement on Mars in 2046. In this activity, learners are encouraged to imagine what some of the issues and challenges around digital self-determination and the social contract might look like on a new human settlement in space.
The Red Skies Project guide can be found here in case you are interested in borrowing or adapting it for your own purposes.
In the original sprint, we did not have new artifacts to build for this week but we encourage you, especially if you have been going through each of the modules, at this point to start to think about what you might contribute to the discussion on Digital Self-Determination. This can be done in several ways. You could add artifacts to some of these modules or you could edit the Wikipedia entry on Digital Self-Determination that the Digital Asia Hub and Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society's Spring 2021 Research Sprint helped to create. You can also engage in conversation with other folks on the topics in general or by using the hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination.
Regardless of what you do, be sure to share on Twitter or other social media platforms using the following hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination
Juan Diego Ardila: Lecturer and expert in Computational Architecture and Digital Fabrication at Universidad Piloto de Colombia. He holds a Bachelor's Degree in Architecture from Universidad de los Andes and a Masters of Advanced Architecture from the Institute for Advanced Architecture of Catalonia (Barcelona, Spain). Juan Diego has academic and teaching experience as well as industry, construction and fabrication processes. His work focuses on digital fabrication processes applied to architecture, computer-aided design and parametric design architecture.
Andrea Owe: Research Associate at the Global Catastrophic Risk Institute, Andrea holds an M.Phil in Development, Environment and Cultural Change from the University of Oslo, and a BA in Fine Arts. Her research focuses on the ethics of the socio-environmental crisis, global catastrophic and existential risks, human moral progress, the prospect of making terrestrial life multiplanetary, and how AI may benefit holistically in the world.
Source: Digital self-determination/Creativity and the Social Contract, revision 2287025 (CC BY-SA 4.0).
This final module highlights the ideas and work that participants in the original research sprint engaged with during the two months it ran in Spring 2021. For learners, we hope this will prove a moment to reflect and consider how they have explored digital self-determination through various lenses (economics, health, media consumption) as well as challenged certain assumptions around the concept. In addition to reflecting on what ideas we have about digital self-determination, we encourage learners to offer recommendations about the key considerations around this subject.
For the final session, we share the recording in its entirety because of its richness, the multitude of voices we had, the various perspectives and questions shared, many of which will accompany us in the coming weeks, maybe months or years. In a way, rather than the last session, it felt like a new beginning: during the last months, all the participants –including the organizers– have faced the complexity of this concept, the depth of the questions it gives rise to, the difficulty of translating these insights into individual and collective actions, civic engagement, policies, and more inclusive, trustworthy digital spaces. We hope the research sprint, its partial and final outputs, and this newsletter contribute to your own reflections, research, and more autonomous use of digital technologies
| Part 1 | Part 2 |
|---|---|
Below are four videos answering the prompt: “Based upon the learning from the sprint, what 3 essential points would you want the Swiss government to hear and consider when doing work in the realm of digital self-determination?”
| Artifact | Author |
|---|---|
| Kyle Chan | |
| Hillary McLauchlin | |
| Carmen Ng | |
| Christian Thönnes |
Based upon the learning from the sprint, learners are encouraged to make a video of no longer than two minutes in duration answering the prompt: what are three essential points that you would want the Swiss government to hear and consider when doing work in the realm of digital self-determination? We encourage you to create these and be sure to share on Twitter or other social media platforms using the following hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination or even add them to this syllabus.
Beyond that, we encourage you, especially if you have been going through each of the modules, at this point to start to think about what you might contribute to the discussion on Digital Self-Determination. This can be done in several ways. You could add artifacts to some of these modules or you could edit the Wikipedia entry on Digital Self-Determination that the Digital Asia Hub and Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society's Spring 2021 Research Sprint helped to create. You can also engage in conversation with other folks on the topics in general or by using the hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination.
Regardless of what you do, be sure to share on Twitter or other social media platforms using the following hashtag: #DigitalSelfDetermination
While the original impetus for this syllabus and materials was the Digital Asia Hub and Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society's 2021 Research Sprint, we encourage others to share summations, resources, and content.
During the Spring 2021, the Center for Internet and Society at the Rosario University (ISUR) in Bogota, Colombia, has conducted a parallel research sprint on “autodeterminación digital” (digital self-determination), based on the DAH-BKC research sprint plan. ISUR research sprint has been hosted by the Faculty of Law at Universidad del Rosario and has had ten former and current bachelor’s students as participants. Further information and some of their artifacts are located on this document.
Roger Dubach
Roger Dubach, born in 1974, studied Law at the University of Fribourg (Switzerland) and Philosophy at the University of Louvain-la-Neuve (Belgium). In 2003, he joined the diplomatic service of the Federal Department of Foreign Affairs and was appointed as a Diplomatic Advisor to the Director of the Federal Office for Energy in 2006. In this and his next function as Energy Counsellor at the Swiss Mission to the EU in Brussels, he acted as Technical Director of the energy negotiations between Switzerland and the EU. In 2013, he was appointed as a Personal Advisor to the Federal Councillor Doris Leuthard, and later as Deputy Director of the Task Force for the Swiss OSCE Chairmanship. Between 2016 and 2018, he served as Diplomatic Advisor on G7 and G20 issues in the Cabinet of the OECD Secretary-General in Paris, and was appointed by the Federal Council in August 2018 as an Ambassador and Deputy Director of the Directorate of International Law.
Source: Digital self-determination/Reimagining Digital Self-Determination, revision 2287021 (CC BY-SA 4.0).