Horseshoe Bay Proper vs. Neighbors: Price and Speed Compared

Deal of the Week

114 Rolling Hill DR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
Deals of the Week by price quartile. The quartiles come from the last 12 months of closed sales here. Each pick has the top ALEX deal score in its price range. Lower quartile: under $514,000 114 Rolling Hill DR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 · MLS #7472785 Listed at $490,000, 3 bed, 2 bath, 2,061 sq ft. The top-scoring home for sale here this week on price per sq ft, price changes and time on market; 4% under the local price per sq ft. See it on alex.realestate: https://www.alex.realestate/listing?q=114+Rolling+Hill+DR%2C+Horseshoe+Bay%2C+TX Upper-middle quartile: $586,000 to $891,000 100 Semi CIR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 · MLS #3879316 Listed at $592,410, 5 bed, 3.5 bath, 3,255 sq ft. The top-scoring home for sale here this week on price per sq ft, price changes and time on market; 27% under the local price per sq ft; price reduced 1% from original. See it on alex.realestate: https://www.alex.realestate/listing?q=100+Semi+CIR%2C+Horseshoe+Bay%2C+TX Upper quartile: $891,000 and up 1107 The Cape # 12, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 · MLS #5602425 Listed at $1,995,000, 4 bed, 4 bath, 3,037 sq ft. Listed 0% below the ALEX valuation. See it on alex.realestate: https://www.alex.realestate/listing?q=1107+The+Cape+%23+12%2C+Horseshoe+Bay%2C+TX

Key figures · Horseshoe Bay Proper, Horseshoe Bay · rolling 12 months ending Oct 31, 2026

Source: Unlock MLS, rolling 12 months ending Oct 31, 2026. Single-family homes; prices net of seller-paid concessions, the same figures as the ALEX market statistics pages. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Market figures by town

How does the Horseshoe Bay Proper market compare to its broader region and county neighbors? A look at the data reveals a distinct profile where prices remain elevated but transaction speeds are catching up. Across 32 closed sales in the rolling 12 months ending October 31, 2026, the median close price for single-family homes in Horseshoe Bay Proper stood at $583,000. This figure is significantly higher than the regional median of $398,500 and also exceeds the Llano County median of $542,500. The premium per square foot tells a similar story, with local homes selling for a median of $243.31 compared to $197.56 regionally and $267.12 in Llano County. Market velocity also shows divergence. Homes in Horseshoe Bay Proper spent a median of 92 days on market. While this is slower than the regional average of 66 days, it represents a notable improvement over the prior period's 162 days and matches the same window from last year. In contrast, Llano County homes took a median of 131 days to sell. The price-to-list dynamic further distinguishes this community. Sellers in Horseshoe Bay Proper achieved a median close-to-original list ratio of 0.91, meaning homes sold for 91% of the original asking price. This is slightly lower than the regional average of 0.939 but higher than the Llano County average of 0.835. Additionally, 96.9% of sales closed below the original list price, a rate consistent with both the prior period and the same time last year, indicating stable negotiation dynamics despite the higher price point. ALEX Intelligence analyzed these comparative figures to highlight how Horseshoe Bay Proper maintains a premium valuation while adjusting its sales velocity relative to surrounding areas. The data suggests a market that is resilient in pricing but requires patience comparable to the broader region. Want to see this home? Call or text George at 713.918.9951 for a private showing. Data from Unlock MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Model outputs are ALEX Intelligence estimates, not appraisals. Read more Central Texas market data on the ALEX blog: https://alex-companies.com/blog
George Arnold Alexander III, MPA
Partner, ALEX Companies
Associate Broker, Alexander Tiffany Southwest, LLC
Licensed Broker in TX, CO, NC, AL
[email protected] · +1 713.918.9951
TREC Information About Brokerage Services · TREC Consumer Protection Notice
Source data: Unlock MLS closed sales, rolling 12 months ending Oct 31, 2026, n=32
Find this home on alex.realestateDownload the PDFDownload the videoSchedule a showing
Slide 1Slide 2Slide 3Slide 4Slide 5Slide 6Slide 7Slide 8Slide 9Slide 10Slide 11
Licensed by the Texas Real Estate Commission. Broker: Alexander Tiffany Southwest, LLC · License #565194-BB.
Diane Hart Alexander, Chair & CEO, ALEX Companies · Designated Broker · #574877-B  ·  George Arnold Alexander III, Partner, ALEX Companies · Associate Broker · #574878-B
Texas Real Estate Commission Information About Brokerage Services · TREC Consumer Protection Notice · trec.texas.gov