| George Arnold Alexander III, MPA |
| Partner, ALEX Companies |
| Associate Broker, Alexander Tiffany Southwest, LLC |
| Licensed Broker in TX, CO, NC, AL |
| [email protected] · +1 713.918.9951 |
| TREC Information About Brokerage Services · TREC Consumer Protection Notice |
Horseshoe Bay vs. Neighbors: Price and Speed Gap
By George Arnold Alexander III, MPA · Associate Broker · 2026-11-20
Deal of the Week
Deals of the Week by price quartile. The quartiles come from the last 12 months of closed sales here. Each pick has the top ALEX deal score in its price range.
Lower quartile: under $370,000
1302 White Tail RD, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 · MLS #9814929
Listed at $349,900, 3 bed, 2 bath, 1,716 sq ft. The top-scoring home for sale here this week on price per sq ft, price changes and time on market; 32% under the local price per sq ft.
See it on alex.realestate: https://www.alex.realestate/listing?q=1302+White+Tail+RD%2C+Horseshoe+Bay%2C+TX
Lower-middle quartile: $370,000 to $640,000
310 Dogie DR # A, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 · MLS #6754690
Listed at $475,000, 3 bed, 2.5 bath, 2,036 sq ft. The top-scoring home for sale here this week on price per sq ft, price changes and time on market; 22% under the local price per sq ft; price reduced 5% from original.
See it on alex.realestate: https://www.alex.realestate/listing?q=310+Dogie+DR+%23+A%2C+Horseshoe+Bay%2C+TX
Upper-middle quartile: $640,000 to $1,225,000
309 Grove CT, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 · MLS #1947016
Listed at $1,005,000, 3 bed, 3.5 bath, 2,422 sq ft. The top-scoring home for sale here this week on price per sq ft, price changes and time on market; 5% under the local price per sq ft.
See it on alex.realestate: https://www.alex.realestate/listing?q=309+Grove+CT%2C+Horseshoe+Bay%2C+TX
Upper quartile: $1,225,000 and up
3212 Pack Saddle DR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 · MLS #6028867
Listed at $3,700,000, 5 bed, 4.5 bath, 4,764 sq ft. Listed 8% below the ALEX valuation.
See it on alex.realestate: https://www.alex.realestate/listing?q=3212+Pack+Saddle+DR%2C+Horseshoe+Bay%2C+TX
Key figures · Horseshoe Bay 78657 · rolling 6 months ending Oct 31, 2026
- 94 homes sold in Horseshoe Bay 78657 in the 6 months ending Oct 31, 2026 (up 19.0% on a year earlier).
- Median net sale price: $682,250 (down 14.2% on a year earlier).
- Median price per square foot: $275.
- Median days on market: 112.
- Median sale price as a share of the original list price: 91.7%.
- 183 homes for sale now, about 9.2 months of supply at the pace of the last six months.
Source: Unlock MLS, rolling 6 months ending Oct 31, 2026. Single-family homes; prices net of seller-paid concessions, the same figures as the ALEX market statistics pages. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Horseshoe Bay buyers and sellers face a distinct market reality compared to the wider region. The median closed price in Horseshoe Bay stands at $682,250 across 94 sales, which is significantly higher than the regional median of $398,800. This premium reflects the unique lakefront and golf community profile of the area.
Speed of sale also diverges significantly from the broader market. Homes in Horseshoe Bay spent a median of 112 days on the market, compared to a regional median of 66 days. While the local market remains active with 94 closed sales over the last six months, the extended time to close suggests a more deliberate buying process for this specific inventory type.
Price per square foot tells a similar story of premium valuation. The median price per square foot in Horseshoe Bay is $274.53, compared to $197.37 across the region. This gap indicates that buyers are paying a substantial premium for every square foot of living space in this community relative to the general Unlock MLS area.
The data also reveals how local pricing compares to immediate neighbors. In Llano County, the median price is $542,500 with 131 days on market. Horseshoe Bay commands a higher price point but moves slightly faster than the broader county average. This comparison highlights that while Horseshoe Bay is an expensive market, it maintains a distinct velocity compared to its surrounding area.
ALEX Intelligence analyzed these comparative figures to highlight the specific positioning of Horseshoe Bay within the regional landscape. The data shows a clear separation in both value and transaction speed between this community and the broader Unlock MLS region.
Want to see this home? Call or text George at 713.918.9951 for a private showing.
Data from Unlock MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Model outputs are ALEX Intelligence estimates, not appraisals.
Read more market data for Texas, Alabama, Colorado, North Carolina, South Carolina and Tennessee on the ALEX blog: https://alex-companies.com/blog
Source data: Unlock MLS closed sales, rolling 6 months ending Oct 31, 2026, n=94
Get Horseshoe Bay 78657 posts by email
1. Choose places and topics: search by name or browse the lists. 2. Confirm from your inbox.
One email a day at most, links only. Change or stop any time.
Licensed by the Texas Real Estate Commission. Broker: Alexander Tiffany Southwest, LLC · License #565194-BB.
Diane Hart Alexander, Chair & CEO, ALEX Companies · Designated Broker · #574877-B · George Arnold Alexander III, Partner, ALEX Companies · Associate Broker · #574878-B
Texas Real Estate Commission Information About Brokerage Services · TREC Consumer Protection Notice · trec.texas.gov
Diane Hart Alexander, Chair & CEO, ALEX Companies · Designated Broker · #574877-B · George Arnold Alexander III, Partner, ALEX Companies · Associate Broker · #574878-B
Texas Real Estate Commission Information About Brokerage Services · TREC Consumer Protection Notice · trec.texas.gov





