Plum Creek vs. Neighbors: Sales and Price Benchmarks

How does the Plum Creek market compare to its immediate neighbors and the wider region? ALEX Intelligence analyzed 107 closed sales over the last six months to benchmark performance against Hays County and the broader Unlock MLS region. The median closing price in Plum Creek remains steady at $310,000, matching the prior six-month period but sitting below the $373,000 median for Hays County and the $403,000 regional average. This price gap reflects a market where homes are selling at a lower price point per square foot ($170) compared to the region's $205. Activity in Plum Creek is notably faster than the broader area. Homes sold in 40 days on average, significantly quicker than the 70-day median in Hays County and the 57-day regional average. However, buyers are negotiating more aggressively; 84% of homes closed below their original list price, a rate slightly higher than the 79% seen in Hays County. Inventory levels suggest a balanced environment with 2.6 months of supply available today. While Plum Creek offers faster turnover and lower entry prices, the region as a whole commands higher valuations. This comparison highlights how local community dynamics can diverge from county-wide trends even within the same market ecosystem. Want to see this home? Call or text George at 713.918.9951 for a private showing. Data from Unlock MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Model outputs are ALEX Intelligence estimates, not appraisals. Read more Central Texas market data on the ALEX blog: https://alex-companies.com/blog